Recruiting New Teachers to Urban School Districts: What Incentives Will Work?

Anthony Thomas Milanowski, Hope Longwell-Grice, Felicia Saffold, Janice Jones, Kristen Schomisch, Allan Odden

Abstract


Many urban districts in the United States have difficulty attracting and retaining quality teachers, yet they are often the most in need of them. In response, U.S. states and districts are experimenting with financial incentives to attract and retain high-quality teachers in high-need, low-achieving, or hard-to-staff urban schools. However, relatively little is known about how effective financial incentives are to recruit new teachers to high-need urban schools. This research explores factors that are important to the job choices of teachers in training. Focus groups were held with students at three universities, and a policy-capturing study was done using 64 job scenarios representing various levels of pay and working conditions. Focus group results suggested that: a) many pre-service teachers, even relatively late in their preparation, are not committed to a particular district and are willing to consider many possibilities, including high need schools; b) although pay and benefits were attractive to the students, loan forgiveness and subsidies for further education were also attractive; and c) small increments of additional salary did not appear as important or attractive as other job characteristics. The policy-capturing study showed that working conditions factors, especially principal support, had more influence on simulated job choice than pay level, implying that money might be better spent to attract, retain, or train better principals than to provide higher beginning salaries to teachers in schools with high-poverty or a high proportion of students of color.

Keywords


teacher compensation;job choice;new teachers

Full Text:

PDF


DOI: https://doi.org/10.22230/ijepl.2009v4n8a132

Copyright (c) 2015 Anthony Thomas Milanowski, Hope Longwell-Grice, Felicia Saffold, Janice Jones, Kristen Schomisch, Allan Odden

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.