Drivers and Interpretations of Doctoral Education Today: National Comparisons

Main Article Content

Lesley Andres
Søren S.E. Bengtsen
Liliana Gallego Castaño
Barbara Crossouard
Jeffrey M Keefer
Kirsi Pyhältö

Abstract

In the last decade, doctoral education has undergone a sea change with several global trends increasingly apparent. Drivers of change include massification and professionalization of doctoral education and the introduction of quality assurance systems. The impact of these drivers, and the forms that they take, however, are dependent on doctoral education within a given national context. This paper is frontline in that it contributes to the literature on doctoral education by examining the ways in which these global trends and drivers are being taken up in policies and practices by various countries. We do so by comparing recent changes in each of the following countries: Canada, Colombia, Denmark, Finland, the UK, and the USA. Each country case is based on national education policies, policy reports on doctoral education (e.g., OECD and EU policy texts), and related materials. We use the same global drivers to examine educational policies of each country. However, depending each national context, these drivers are framed in considerably different ways. This raises questions about (1) their comparability at a global level and (2) the universality of the PhD. Also we find that this global-local nexus reveals unresolved tensions within the national doctoral educational frameworks. 

Article Details

How to Cite
Andres, L., Bengtsen, S. S., Gallego Castaño, L., Crossouard, B., Keefer, J. M., & Pyhältö, K. (2015). Drivers and Interpretations of Doctoral Education Today: National Comparisons. Frontline Learning Research, 3(3), 5–22. https://doi.org/10.14786/flr.v3i3.177
Section
Articles
Author Biography

Lesley Andres, University of British Columbia

Department of Educational Studies

Full Professor

References

Academy of Finland. (2010). Get ahead in our career. Get a doctorate. Retrieved from http://aka.smartpage.fi/en/doctors_career/

Andras, P. (2011). Research: Metrics, quality, and management implications. Research Evaluation, 20(2), 90–106. doi: 10.3152/095820211X12941371876265

Auriol, L., Misu, M., & Freeman, R. A. (2013). Careers of doctorate holders: Analysis of labour market and mobility indicators. OECD Science, Technology and Industry Working Papers, 2013/04. OECD Publishing. doi: 10.1787/5k43nxgs289w-en

Auriol, L., Schaaper, M., & Felix, B. (2012). Mapping careers and mobility of doctorate holders: Draft guidelines, model questionnaire and indicators – Third Edition. OECD Science, Technology and Industry Working Papers, 2012/07. OECD Publishing. doi: 10.1787/5k4dnq2h4n5c-en

Berlin Communiqué. (2003). Realising the European higher education area. Conference of ministers responsible for higher education in 33 European countries (September).

Brunner, J. J. (2001). Globalización y el futuro de la educación: tendencias, desafíos, estrategias. Análisis de Prospectivas de la Educación en América Latina y el Caribe. Santiago de Chile: UNESCO.

Bucharest Communiqué. (2012). Making the most of our potential: Consolidating the European higher education area. Retrieved from http://www.ehea.info/Uploads/%281%29/Bucharest%20Communique%202012%281%29.pdf

Buela-Casal, G., Gutiérrez-Martínez, O., Bermúdez-Sánchez, M. P., & Vadillo-Muñoz, O. (2007). Comparative study of international academic rankings of universities. Scientometrics, 71(3), 349-365.

Conference Board of Canada. (2014). How Canada performs. Retrieved from http://www.conferenceboard.ca/hcp/provincial/education/phd.aspx

Danish Ministry of Higher Education and Science (2015a) . Official website. Direct link (to Danish text version): http://ufm.dk/uddannelse-og-institutioner/videregaende-uddannelse/universiteter/ph-d-uddannelse/ph-d-skoler

Danish Ministry of Higher Education and Science (2015b) . Official website. Direct link (to Danish text version): http://ufm.dk/uddannelse-og-institutioner/anerkendelse-og-dokumentation/dokumentation/kvalifikationsrammer/europaeisk-kvalifikationsramme-eqf

Department for Education and Skills (DfES). (2003). The future of higher education. London: HMSO.

DePietro-Jurand, R., & Lemaitre, M. J. (2002). Quality assurance in Colombia. Colombia: Tertiary education Paving the way for reform, Vol. 2. The World Bank, Report No. 23935-CO.

Edler, J., Georhiou,L., Blind, K., & Uyrra, E. (2012). Evaluating the demand side: New challenges for evaluation. Research Evaluation, 21, 33-47.

Elgar, F. J. (2003). PhD degree completion in Canadian universities: Final report. Halifax: Graduate Students Association of Canada.

ESF (European Science Foundation). (2009). Research careers in Europe: Landscape and horizons. A report by the ESF Member Organisation Forum on research careers. ESF, Strasbourg. Retrieved from http://www.esf.org/fileadmin/links/CEO/ResearchCareers_60p%20A4_13Jan.pdf

EUA (European University Association). (2009). Collaborative doctoral education: University-industry partnerships for enhancing knowledge exchange. EUA, Brussels. Retrieved from http://www.eua.be/eua-work-and-policy-area/research-and-innovation/doctoral-education/doc-careers/

EUA (European University Association). (2010). Salzburg II recommendations: European universities’ achievements since 2005 in implementing the Salzburg principles. EUA, Brussels. Retrieved from http://www.eua.be/News/10-10-28/EUA_publishes_recommendations_for_continued_reform_of_doctoral_education.aspx

European Commission. (2014). European research area progress report. Brussels, European Commission. Retrieved from http://ec.europa.eu/research/era/eraprogress_en.htm

Fernandez-Zubieta, A. & Guy, K. (2010). Developing the European research area: Improving knowledge flows via researcher mobility. JCR Scientific and Technical reports. European Commission. Retrieved from http://erawatch.jrc.ec.europa.eu/erawatch/opencms/information/reports/countries/eu/report_0020

Finnish Ministry of Education (1997). Tutkijakoulut Suomessa 1995–1998. Tutkijakouluissa annettavan opetuksen ja ohjauksen laadun arviointi [Doctoral schools in Finland 1995-1998.]. Opetusministeriö, Koulutus- ja tiedepolitiikan osasto.

Fiske, P. (2011). What is a PhD really worth? Nature, 472, 381. doi:10.1038/nj7343-381a

Fortes, M., Kehm, B. M., & Mayekiso, T. (2014). Evaluation and Quality Management in Europe, Mexico, and South Africa. In M. Nerad & B. Evans (Eds.), Globalization and Its Impacts on the Quality of PhD Education (pp. 81–110). Springer: Rotterdam.

Frank, R. H. (1999). Higher education: The ultimate winner-take-all market? Ithica, NY. Retrieved from http://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/cheri/2/

Garam, I. (2013) Kansainvälinen liikkuvuus yliopistoissa ja ammattikorkeakouluissa 2013. Tietoja ja tilastoja -raportti 2/2014. Centre for International Mobility CIMO. Retrieved from http://www.cimo.fi/instancedata/prime_product_julkaisu/cimo/embeds/cimowwwstructure/32368_Tietoa_ja_tilastoja-raportti_2_2014.pdf

Geuna, A., & Martin, B. (2003). University Research Evaluation and Funding: An International Comparison, Minerva, 41(4), 277-304.

Gilbert, R., Balatti, J., Turner, P., & Whitehouse, H. (2004). The generic skills debate in research higher degrees. Higher Education Research & Development, 23(3), 375-388.

Grafton, A. T., & Grossman, J. (2011, October). No more Plan B: A very modest proposal for graduate programs in history. Historians.org. Retrieved November 1, 2014, from http://historians.org/publications-and-directories/perspectives-on-history/october-2011/no-more-plan-b

Green, B. (2009). Challenging perspectives, challenging practices. Doctoral education in transition. In Boud, D. & Lee, A. (Eds.). Changing Practices of Doctoral Education. London & New York: Routledge.

Gudmundsson, H.K. (2008). Nordic Countries. In Nerad, M., & Heggelund, M. (Eds.). Toward a Global PhD? Forces & Forms in Doctoral Education Worldwide. Seattle & London: University of Washington Press.

Hsieh, H.-F., & Shannon, S. E. (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 15(9), 1277–1288. doi:10.1177/1049732305276687

Institute for Employment Research. (2003). Bulletin: Women in Science, Engineering and Technology. University of Warwick: Warwick.

Institute for the Public Life of Arts and Ideas. (2013). White Paper on the Future of the PhD in the Humanities. Montreal: McGill University.

Jaramillo Salazar, H. (2009). La formación de posgrado en Colombia. Revista iberoamericana de ciencia tecnología y sociedad, 5(13), 131-155. Disponible en: . ISSN 1850-0013.

Jaramillo, I. C. (2003). La internacionalización de la Educación Superior y su Dinámica en Colombia. The Wold Bank. Latin American and the Caribbean Regional Office.

Jaschik, S. (2014, March 20). A broader history Ph.D. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved November 1, 2014, from https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2014/03/20/historians-association-and-four-doctoral-programs-start-new-effort-broaden-phd

June, A. W. (2014, May 12). Doctoral degrees increased last year, but career opportunities remained bleak. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved January 4, 2015, from http://chronicle.com/article/Doctoral-Degrees-Increased/150421/

Kehm, B. M. (2006). Doctoral education in Europe and North America: A comparative analysis. In U. Teichler, The formative years of scholars (Vol. 83, pp. 67–78). London.

Kehm, B. M. (2006). Doctoral education in Europe and North America. A comparative analysis. In U. Teichler (Ed.), The Formative Years of Scholars. Wenner-Gren International Series, Vol. 83 (pp. 67-78). London: Portland Press.

KOTA-National Data Base. (2009). Retrieved from https://kotaplus.csc.fi/online/Transfer.do

Lederman, D. (2014, August 12). Doctorates up, career prospects not. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved January 4, 2015, from https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2014/12/08/number-phds-awarded-climbs-recipients-job-prospects-dropping

Manathunga, C. (2005). The Development of Research Supervision: “Turning the light on a private space”. International Journal for Academic Development. 10(1), 17-30.

MLA Task Force on Doctoral Study in Modern Language and Literature. (2014). Report of the MLA task force on doctoral study in modern language and literature, 1–41.

Moguérou, P., & Di Pietrogiacomo, M. P. (2008). Stock, career and mobility of researchers in the EU. JCR Scientific and Technical reports. European Comission. Retrieved from http://erawatch.jrc.ec.europa.eu/erawatch/opencms/information/reports/countries/eu/report_mig_0011

Morley, L. (2004). Interrogating doctoral assessment. International Journal of Educational Research, 41(2), 91-97.

Morley, L., Leonard, D., and David, M. (2002). Variations in Vivas: quality and equality in British PhD assessments. Studies in Higher Education, 27(3), 263-273.

National Committee of Inquiry into Higher Education (The Dearing Report). (1997). Higher education in the learning society. HMSO: London.

National Science Foundation (NSF). (n.d.). Early career doctorates project (forthcoming). Nsf.Gov. Retrieved November 1, 2014, from http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/srvyecd/

National Science Foundation. Doctorate recipients from U.S. universities 2012: Survey of earned doctorates. National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics. Retrieved from http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/srvydoctorates/

Neem, J. (2014, October 3). Ministers, not M.B.A.s. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved November 1, 2014, from https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2014/10/03/humanities-phd-calling-not-vocational-training-essay

Niemi, H., Aittola, H., Harmaakorpi, V., Lassila, O., Svärd, S., Ylikarjula, J., Hiltunen, K., & Talvinen, K. (2011). Tohtorikoulutuksen rakenteet muutoksessa: Tohtorikoulutuksen kansallinen seuranta-arviointi [Changing structures of doctoran education: National follow-up evaluation of doctoral education]. Korkeakoulujen Arviointineuvoston Julkaisuja, 15.

OECD (2010). The OECD innovation strategy: Getting a head start on tomorrow. Paris: OECD.

OECD (2012). Transferable skills training for researchers: Supporting career development and research. OECD Publishing. doi: 10.1787/9789264179721-en

OECD (2014). Education at a glance 2014: OECD indicators. OECD Publishing. doi: 10.1787/eag-2014-en

Patel, V. (2015, January 12). New job on campus: Expanding Ph.D. career options. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved January 19, 2015, from http://chronicle.com/article/New-Job-on-Campus-Expanding/151105/?key=SG16IVRgNicWM3BnZGlANjhROH1sNBwjanFJbCgkbllXFg%3D%3D

Park, C. (2007). Redefining the doctorate. Higher Education Academy, York.

Pearson, M. & Brew, A. (2002). Research Training and Supervision Development. Studies in Higher Education, 27(2), 135-150.

Puhakka, A., & Rautopuro, J. (2013). Sumusta nousee riski – Tieteentekijöiden liiton jäsenkysely [The Finnish Union of University Researchers and Teachers Membership survey]. Joensuu: Grano. Retrieved in http://tieteentekijoidenliitto.fi/materiaali/jasenkyselyraportit

Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (QAA). (2004). Code of practice for the assurance of academic quality and standards in higher education. Section 1: Postgraduate research programmes. Gloucester: QAA.

República de Colombia, Ministerio de Educación Nacional (MEN) (2010). Consejo Nacional de Acreditación (CNA). Lineamientos para la acreditación de alta calidad de programas de maestría y Doctorado. 2010, Bogotá. Retrieved November 12, 2014 In http://cms-static.colombiaaprende.edu.co/cache/binaries/articles-186363_lineam_MyD.pdf?binary_rand=7259

Rizen, J., & Marconi, G. (2011). Internationalization in European higher education. International Journal of Innovation Science, 3(2), 83-100.

Roberts, G. (2002). SET for success. Final report of Sir Gareth Roberts review. London: HMSO.

Rugby Team. (2006). Evaluation of skills development of early career researchers - a strategy paper from the Rugby Team. UK GRAD Programme Roberts policy forum. Birmingham: UK GRAD.

Sainio, J. (2010). Asiantuntijana työmarkkinoille. Vuosina 2006 ja 2007 tohtorin tutkinnon suorittaneiden työllistyminen ja heidän mielipiteitään tohtorikoulutuksesta [As an expert to the labour market. Employment of those receiving a doctorate in 2006 and 2007, and their opinions about doctoral education]. Aarresaaren julkaisusarja. Retrieved from https://www.aarresaari.net/uraseuranta/julkaisut

Sinche, M. (2014, October 27). Tracking Ph.D. career paths. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved November 1, 2014, from https://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2014/10/27/essay-importance-tracking-phd-career-paths

Shin, J. C. (2010). Impacts of performance-based accountability on institutional performance in US. Higher Education, 60(1), 47-68

Shin, J. C. & J. Jung (2014). Academic job satisfaction and job stress across countries in changing academic environments. Higher Education, 67, 603-620

Tamburri, R. (2013, Feb 06). The PhD is in need of revision. University Affairs. Retrieved from http://www.universityaffairs.ca/features/feature-article/the-phd-is-in-need-of-revision/

Teichler, U. (2004). The Changing Debate on Internationalisation of Higher Education, Higher Education,
48 (1), 5-26.

The Graduate School Working Group, (2012). Towards Quality, Transparency and Predictability in Doctoral Training. The Graduate School Working Group’s Suggestions for Doctoral Training Development. Academy of Finland. Retrieved from http://www.aka.fi/en-GB/A/Academy-of-Finland/Academy-publications/Other-publications/

The World Bank. (2003). Colombian tertiary education in the context of reform in Latin America. Colombia: Tertiary Education Paving the Way for Reform Vol. 1. Policy Briefing. The World Bank, Report No. 23935-CO.

Treuthardt, L., & Nuutinen, A. (2012). The State of Scientific Research in Finland 2012. Publications of Academy of Finland 7/2012. Retrieved from http://www.aka.fi/en-GB/A/Decisions-and-impacts/The-state-of-scientific-research-in-Finland/Previous-reviews/The-state-of-scientific-research-in-Finland-20121/

UK Council for Science and Technology. (2007). Pathways to the Future: the early career of researchers in the UK. CST, London.

U.S. Department of Education Office of Postsecondary Education (OPE). (n.d.). The database of accredited postsecondary institutions and programs. Http://Ope.Ed.Gov/Accreditation. Retrieved October 19, 2014, from http://ope.ed.gov/accreditation

UBC Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies. (2014). Re-imagining the PhD: New forms and futures for graduate education. Symposium Summary Report. Vancouver: University of British Columbia. Retrieved from http://www.ligi.ubc.ca/sites/liu/files/News/UBCGraduateSymposiumReport2014.pdf

UNESCO-IBE. (2011). World data on Education VII Ed. 2010/11. [Retrieved in november , 2014]. In http://www.ibe.unesco.org //

Universities UK. (2014). International students in higher education: The UK and its competition. London: UUK.

Vitae. (2010). Researcher Development Statement. Vitae and CRAC: Cambridge

Willetts, J., Mitcell, C., Abeysuriya, K., & Fam, D. (2012). Creative tensions. Negotiating the multiple dimensions of a transdisciplinary doctorate. In Lee, A. & Danby, S. (Eds.). Reshaping Doctoral Education. International approaches and pedagogies. London & New York: Routledge.

Yesko, J. (2014, July 25). An alternative to ABD. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved November 1, 2014, from https://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2014/07/25/higher-ed-should-create-alternative-abd-status-essay

Yin, R. K. (2012). Applications of case study research (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.